Best Burgers in Austintown, OH

When you have a craving for a burger, not just any burger will do. You want something high quality that’s perfectly seasoned, juicy, savory, and even cheesy. Whether you’re seeking traditional American flavors with crisp lettuce and cool tomatoes, or something adventurous topped with an egg, there are several options for you in the area. Read on to learn about our list of restaurants where you can score the best burgers in Austintown, Ohio.

Mojo’s Pub-N-Grill

No burger joint list in Austintown, Ohio, is complete without Mojo’s Pub-N-Grill. This establishment features classic American and pub fare to make your mouth water. This American pub started up in 2004 as a mere idea and quickly blossomed into one of the go-to places for great food, drinks, and atmosphere. The environment is extremely inviting, and the burgers are so juicy and delicious that you’ll forget about the fries. In addition to the amazing burgers, you can get other great dishes, such as barbecue platters, a perfectly grilled Mojo ribeye, chicken alfredo, lasagna, or fish.

You’ll find the fun and creative menu is based on American pop culture and rock and roll music. If you’re a Doors fan, you’ll love the Morrison Burger. This is Mojo’s classic burger topped with Jack cheese, bacon, and Mojo’s specialty barbecue sauce. If you want something that has some tang, order the James Brown and Blue Burger. This tasty menu item is topped with grilled onions, a generous serving of crumbled blue cheese, and bacon. Don’t forget to grab an appetizer of wings to start your meal. They pair perfectly with coke, tea, or beer.

Location: 6292 Mahoning Ave.

Hours: 11:30 a.m. to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Friday, noon to 10 p.m. on Saturday, and noon to 8 p.m. on Sunday

Contact: 330-793-6656

Ice House Inn Sports Bar

Known for having the coldest beer around since 1934, the Ice House Inn Sports Bar is also the place for burgers. The original owner, Joe Mousie, began the Ice House Inn with a focus on his own American Cream. Years later, this is an established restaurant and bar that is welcoming to all and a classic spot to chill and eat for the people of Austintown.

The menu features an array of selections to please almost any palate. If you have a crowd with varying likes, this is the place to go. And any burger lover will be in paradise here. We suggest you begin your meal with some fried pickles off the appetizer menu. Then order yourself one of the best burgers you’ll ever have. The menu keeps things classic, with options such as a bacon cheeseburger served with crisp bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion.

Another popular option is the mushroom Swiss burger, topped with a healthy serving of sauteed button mushrooms and melted Swiss cheese. All burgers are served with a side of house-cut fries or a premium side. If you want to try something different, we suggest you order the onion rings, a great pairing with any burger.

Location: 5516 W. Webb Road

Hours: 11 a.m. to midnight Monday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 2 a.m. Friday and Saturday, and 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. on Sunday

Contact: 330-544-8800

Coaches Burger Bar

For a fun place to let loose after work or to meet up with friends, consider Coaches Burger Bar. This place is a mainstay in Austintown because it honors the hard work and dedication of so many coaches who guide, mentor, and support the youth of the community. The menu has fun appetizers that range from pulled pork nachos and batter-up pretzels to onion tanglers, which are sliced Vidalia onions battered and deep-fried to a golden crisp. But you don’t go to a burger bar for the appetizers.

One burger that’s the favorite of the bar’s loyal customers is the Big Texan Burger. This meal is made for a sports and burger fan and features a grilled beef patty and then topped with American cheese, bacon, barbecue sauce, and a generous helping of onion tanglers. You may also consider trying the Sideline Fire Burger. This burger is cooked to medium well, topped with pepper Jack cheese and house-made hot peppers, and then doused in fire sauce. All burgers are served with a side of signature fresh-cut fries.

Location: 5529 Mahoning Ave.

Hours: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. on Monday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. on Friday and Saturday, and 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. on Sunday

Contact: 330-330-8686

The Federal

Situated conveniently in downtown Youngstown, The Federal is a great place where craft beer and burgers make the perfect couple. The team here has given the classic burger a makeover. With a bit of western flair, The Federal ensures that each burger is satisfying and made to order.

Pick yourself up the John Wayne for $15. It’s topped with bacon, grilled onions, cheddar cheese, onion rings, and barbecue sauce. Another great option is the Federal Smash. This hefty order features two 4-ounce signature beef burgers double stacked and topped with shredded lettuce, cheese, pickles, grilled onions, and special burger sauce. Other menu items range from a classic grilled cheese sandwich to spicy chipotle wraps and spicy fried shrimp.

Location: 110 W. Federal St.

Hours: Opens at 11 a.m. daily except Wednesdays

Contact: 330-744-7683

So, there you have it. #1 Cochran Chevrolet has enjoyed sharing the dirt on where to get the best burgers in Austintown, OH. Whether you want the traditional juicy meaty hunk of meat or something more gourmet with unique flavors, you’ll find something to entice your taste buds at one of these fine establishments.

What do you think of our list? Did we miss your favorite spot to cure your craving for a burger? If we did, please let us know. Leave us a message sharing your thoughts, and we’ll be happy to check out your suggestions. Our team at #1 Cochran is always trying to find the hidden gems of the area. You may even find your idea featured on our list in the future.

Burger by Ken Hawkins is licensed with CC BY 2.0